Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.

A PO Box 352, Millersburg, OH 44654 rescue helping to find loving homes for dogs, cats, rabbits, small animals, birds, horses, reptiles, amphibians, and/or fish, farm-type animals.


Pets at Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.

  • Any
  • Dogs
  • Cats
  • Rabbits
  • Horses
  • Any
  • Baby
  • Puppy
  • Kitten
  • Young
  • Adult
  • Senior
  • Any
  • Male
  • Female


Female, Adult
Cavalier King Charles Spaniel


Male, Puppy
Cocker Spaniel


Male, Puppy, Special Needs
Cocker Spaniel


Female, Adult, Bonded Pair
Newfoundland / Labrador Retriever


Male, Adult, Bonded Pair
Labrador Retriever


Female, Adult
Labrador Retriever


Male, Adult
Labrador Retriever


Female, Adult


Male, Adult
Yorkie, Yorkshire Terrier


Male, Adult
Cocker Spaniel


Male, Adult
Shiba Inu

Tiger Lily

Female, Adult
Presa Canario


Female, Adult


Female, Adult
Miniature Schnauzer


Female, Adult, Special Needs
Bichon Frise


Female, Adult
American Bulldog


Female, Puppy
Black and Tan Coonhound


Female, Young


Female, Young
Domestic Shorthair


Female, Young

Page 1 of 2

1 - 20 of 22 Adoptable Pets at This Shelter

Areas Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc. Serves

We serve Holmes County, Ohio, and the surrounding areas

Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.'s Adoption Process

Our process is very easy...there is a link to an adoption form on the page for each animal. Find a pet you're interested in adopting, and click the link to complete the adoption form. We'll review it, contact your references, and get in touch with the homes we believe to be the best match. We make no guarantees of working in any order of receipt...we're looking for the proper home for our dogs, not just whoever can fill out the form the fastest! No offense intended, please.

About Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.

It all started with one family in Northern Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (yes, THAT Lancaster County). They started reaching out to local Puppy breeders, and they convinced quite a few of them that it's better to place their dogs into a loving home than to continue doing what they used to do with a dog they no longer wanted. In the many years since that humble beginning in 1998, we've grown from a family operation into having dozens of volunteers, supporters, and friends, all of whom are dedicated to the same task: Saving their lives!

We also rescue cats from local farms, families, and nearby kill shelters. We've also found homes for rabbits, finches, guinea pigs, maccaws, snakes, frogs, turtles, goats, sheep, pigs, horses and even an alligator!

We do not have a shelter facility that you can visit, as we do all our housing and care through foster homes and volunteers. But we do bring our dogs and cats to Pet Valu in Ephrata Pa. We will make appointments for approved adopters to come meet the animal, and see if the animal adopts them (it's far more important that the animal is happy, as they've had the much more difficult life).

PLEASE NOTE: We are, as it says above, a family-based effort, and that must come first in everything we do! All our volunteers have families that always take precidence over other activities. So if anyone is slow to respond to you, or we take more time than you might think is proper, chalk it up to being parents first, and animal rescuers second! We hope you understand...

Come Meet Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.'s Pets

Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc.'s Adopted Pets

See Adopted Pets List

Make a donation to Plain & Fancy Animal Rescue. Inc. to help homeless pets find homes