American Shorthair kittens & cats in Plymouth, Wisconsin

You can fill out an adoption application online on our official website.Custard, along with her sister Pudding, and her four brothers were living under a backyard shed before being rescued. While Custard is the shyest one of the group, she is still very playful and lovable. She does enjoy a good romp with her siblings, but tends to like more alone time. She loves wet food and treats. She can be a little hard to tell apart from her sister, except she has an extra toe on her back feet, while Pudding does not. Being that they are both female red tabbies AND polydactyl makes them especially unique. Kittens should be adopted in pairs, unless you already have a younger kitty.  If you would like to know more about Custard or are interested in possibly adopting, email us at purrfectmatch13@gmail.com or call 920-234-5995. To potentially adopt, we ask that you fill out a non-binding adoption application on our website: http://purrfectmatch.rescuegroups.org/forms. Visit this organization's web site to see any additional information available about this pet.September 5, 2026, 11:23 pm

You can fill out an adoption application online on our official website.Cheesecake earned his name by being the first one to come to his foster mom, just minutes after arriving (he can be quite the ham). Rescued from living under a shed with his five siblings, Cheesecake is the smallest of the Dessert Litter. While he is smaller in stature, he is big on love. He is super affectionate and loves to cuddle. His purr will sooth you to sleep. When he isn't sleeping or eating, he can be found playing with one of his litter mates or climbing a cat tower. A home with one of his siblings would be best.  If you would like to know more about Cheesecake or are interested in possibly adopting, email us at purrfectmatch13@gmail.com or call 920-234-5995. To potentially adopt, we ask that you fill out a non-binding adoption application on our website: http://purrfectmatch.rescuegroups.org/forms.Visit this organization's web site to see any additional information available about this pet.September 5, 2026, 11:23 pm

You can fill out an adoption application online on our official website. Pudding, along with her sister Custard, and her four brothers were living under a backyard shed before being rescued. Pudding is very sweet and loves to let you know when she's ready for a little attention.  She likes to give little love nips then kiss your finger as an apology. She can be a little hard to tell apart from her sister, except she does not have an extra toe on her back feet, while Custard does. Being that they are both female red tabbies AND polydactyl makes them especially unique. Kittens should be adopted in pairs, unless you already have a younger kitty.  If you would like to know more about Pudding or are interested in possibly adopting, email us at purrfectmatch13@gmail.com or call 920-234-5995. To potentially adopt, we ask that you fill out a non-binding adoption application on our website: http://purrfectmatch.rescuegroups.org/forms. Visit this organization's web site to see any additional information available about this pet.September 5, 2026, 11:23 pm

Kareem LOVES people. He is an incredibly snuggly cat that enjoys his family and anyone who walks through the door, friends and strangers alike. We adopted him and his littermate from our local humane society when he was a kitten and he is now 5 years old. He loves attention, being on your lap, kneading, playing, treats, and watching birds out the window. He is the star of the show if you have friends and family over, plopping to be pet as soon as they walk in the door. A few months ago, he developed redirected aggression toward his littermate brother after I stepped on his tail. After multiple failed attempts to get them to live together peacefully, we have made the tough decision to re-home Kareem. Since Kareem is extremely outgoing and loving, we feel he would do well in a new home.

Meet Jerry, a sweet, goofball, all-white cat with two charming little gray spots on his head who has been a beloved member of our family since 2018(July 22, 2018 born). Over the years, Jerry has proven to be an affectionate companion, but with our family growing to include two young children, we are finding ourselves unable to give him the dedicated time and attention he truly deserves. We are looking to rehome Jerry with an individual, couple, or family who can provide him with a loving, stable environment where he can be the center of attention and soak up all the affection he loves to receive.Older children are ok.

Midnight is a demanding cuddle bug - he wants lots of pets! He's 10 years old and has no health issues, except for a few chipped teeth he got when we adopted him last December from the Humane Society. He's proven to have a big personality that is nothing but endearing. He's playful, energetic, and loves to jump on top of everything, for he is... King of Every Mountain! His adoption paperwork suggested that he previously lived with many humans and animals. He and our other black cat would sometimes cuddle into one giant black void in the hallway, but I would say describing him as 'indifferent' to other cats is accurate. My small dog wanted to play with him, but he put her in her place. She would freeze up around him sometimes, and he would then rub up on her. He wasn't a fan of her, but they coexisted just fine for the 6 months. Now that our lives have fallen apart, I just want to find him a loving home. He was my ESA and took that job seriously. As a solo pet, he'd be amazing!